Ask some accountants or a business broker whether an owner-manager should sell their business to an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) and you might well get a raised eyebrow. Their objection is simple. The trust has no money of its own, so the company pays the selling shareholder(s) out of its own cash balances and future profits. In other words, the trust is buying your company with your company’s money and its future profits. Why not just keep the business, carry on taking the profits as salary or dividends and sell the company when you want to retire, to someone who will pay you with their own money?
On a spreadsheet, it can look a persuasive argument. But it rests on an assumption that rarely holds true in real life: that you, the owner, can keep running the business at full strength forever. You can't or you won’t want to. Once you factor in that reality, and the tax savings on top that come with EOT Relief, the sale of the company to an EOT usually turns out to be one of the most sensible and financially rewarding exits available.
The objection: "it's your own money"
It is worth being clear about how a sale to an EOT works because the critics are not entirely wrong.
A trust is set up to purchase a controlling stake in the company on behalf of all its employees. The trust buys your shares at market value, supported by an independent valuation. Part of the price is usually paid on completion from any surplus cash held by the company. The rest is owed to you and paid over the following years, typically five to eight years, out of the profits after tax that the business makes.
So yes, the money that pays you comes from the business. But the "it's your own money" argument quietly assumes two things. First, that the profits will keep flowing at today's level or more for as long as you need them to. Second, that taking those profits as salary or dividends is a sensible alternative. Neither stands up well to scrutiny.
On the second point, the tax maths is stark. Profits drawn as dividends are taxed at up to 39.35%. The same profits, paid to you as the price for your shares in a qualifying EOT sale, are taxed as a capital gain at an effective rate of around 12%. It may be "your money" either way, but the EOT lets you keep a great deal more of it.
The first point, whether those profits will keep coming at all, is where most analysis falls short.
Nobody can work forever and most wouldn’t want to
Every owner-managed business has an end date built into it: the day the owner stops. It might be planned retirement in your 60s, a health scare at 55 or simply the moment you realise you no longer want to be the first one in and the last one out. Whatever the reason, at some point you will step back, and the business is either sold to a buyer, is passed to a family member or to the managers, or simply winds down.
The model that says "keep the company and keep taking the profits" has no answer for that day. It treats the business as a permanent annuity. In reality, an owner-dependent business is a potential wasting asset, and its value can start to drain long before the owner finally steps aside.
The sale to an EOT whilst the owner is fully engaged with the business helps prevent this with the sale acting as an incentive for the owner and the company’s managers and other employees and creating the stability and clear timeframe for succession planning.
How businesses can go stale
It’s easy for owners to leave their exit too late. None of the factors happen overnight and are cumulative, which is exactly why it is so easy to get the timing wrong.
• Energy fades.
Running a business is demanding. In your 40s you will happily chase a new contract late at night. In your 60s, understandably, you might be less inclined to. New business development slows, and the pipeline thins.
• Appetite for risk falls.
Owners approaching retirement are naturally reluctant to borrow, invest or take on new premises, people or products. Each decision to wait is reasonable on its own, but together they can leave the business standing still while competitors move on.
• Technology falls behind.
Systems that were modern ten years ago become a burden. Ageing software, paper-based processes, a dated website and no real use of cloud tools, data or AI all chip away at efficiency and make the business less attractive to customers, staff and buyers alike. Catching up gets more expensive the longer it is left.
• Customer relationships age with you.
Many key accounts in smaller businesses rest on personal relationships. As your contacts retire, their successors may have no particular loyalty to you, and that work can quietly drift to younger, hungrier rivals.
• Managers fail to take on the role of the Founder.
The business may have been built with a very able team working beneath the Founder. However, unless succession has been well planned it is rare that they will be able to “step up” fully into leadership roles, once the Founder steps down.
The end result can be a business that is worth considerably less than it was five or ten years earlier. By the time the owner is finally ready to retire and sell, trade buyers may not be interested, private equity may not look at it, and the managers will be wary of taking on the risks and responsibilities of ownership. Too many owners end up selling at a knock down price or simply closing the doors and walking away with little more than the value of any cash left in the bank. All those years of hard work, and little to show for them.
What are the exit options?
Before looking at the options we need to understand the tax regime for a founder selling the shares in their company. Since 26 November 2025, a qualifying sale to an EOT has received 50% relief from capital gains tax. With the higher rate of CGT at 24%, that means an effective rate of just 12% on your gain. The October 2026 Budget left this relief unchanged.
By contrast, a conventional sale to a trade buyer, to private equity or to the company’s management team is taxed at 24%, with only the first part of the gain eligible for Business Asset Disposal Relief at 18%. From 6 April 2027, the lifetime limit for that relief falls from £1m to £500,000, so its value to most owners is small.
We consider below the options for a founder who is aged 55-60, who owns 100% of a company which makes £750k - £1m of EBITDA. The founder would like to reduce their involvement in the business gradually over the next 5 years and retire fully within the next 10 years.
Option 1 – Sell to an EOT, keep working in the business for 5-8 years and implement management succession
The Founder could sell the business to an EOT at a fair market value established by an independent valuation. Market value would typically be the value of surplus cash within the company at the date of sale, plus 5-6 times sustainable EBITDA. We assume in this example the market value is £5m. The Founder receives some of that value upfront (from surplus cash held in the business) with the balance paid from the future profits of the company over a 5-8 year period, following which they retire. The gain from the sale of shares to the EOT will be taxed at a CGT rate of 12%.
Option 2 – Sell to a trade buyer or financial buyer, then retire after the sale completes
For many owner-managers this is a theoretical possibility only, as the business may be too dependent on the founder or a single customer, or possibly just too small. A buyer may price in the risk of any dependence into their purchase price which could result in a much lower price than £5m, or be structured with a significant performance related earnout element stretching over 12-24 months, assuming any buyer can be found at all.
If the business is less dependent on the founder or a single customer, and has a capable management team below, then there should be no discount and the sale proceeds will be taxed as follows (using an example of a company worth £5m sold after April 2027):
On these figures the EOT route leaves the owner around £570,000 better off, albeit that the receipts from a sale to an EOT are spread over 5-8 years, rather than mostly received upfront.
However, we would stress again that the risk of a conventional sale falling through, or transacting at a meaningful discount to £5m (due to dependence on the founder), are significant. Also the earnout element (typically 25% of the overall price) is at a significantly greater risk in a conventional sale with hard year 1 and year 2 targets that must be hit by the business or the earnout payments to the owner (e.g. £1.25m in our £5m sale example) will not be paid.
Option 3 – Retain ownership of the Company until retirement in 5-8 years time, take annual dividends, and then realise the Company’s value through sale or wind down
This option is likely to result in a worse financial outcome for the business owner, compared to Option 1, unless the business has a significant retained value at the retirement date. This is because dividends that have been withdrawn from the Company will be taxed most likely at the 39.35% additional dividend rate compared to the capital receipts taxed at 12% at Option 1. To offset this tax leakage the Company must be capable of being sold at a sensible value when the Founder retires, which as we have noted above is often not the case, particularly for owner-managed businesses.
So when does Option 1 (the sale to an EOT) make sense?
An EOT is not right for everyone. It works best when most of these are true:
• The business is consistently profitable and not highly capital intensive so it can generate the cash to pay you
• You have a realistic valuation in mind. An EOT pays fair market value, not the premium a strategic buyer might offer in a bidding war where there may be synergies
• You are comfortable being paid over time, with most of your money arriving in instalments
• You are thinking about stepping back in the next few years, but maybe not immediately as the business will need your skills under EOT ownership until the time that managers can take on all, or part of your role
We might advise against an EOT if you are young and have a rapidly growing business, where waiting or bringing in growth capital may deliver far more value. We might also advise against it if you have family succession possibilities, because an EOT is permanent and the business cannot be passed on to your children afterwards. Furthermore, the company needs to meet the eligibility tests for EOT Relief for the selling shareholders to benefit from the 12% effective rate of CGT. These eligibility criteria include: the company being sold to the EOT must be a trading company (and not an investment company); and the company must have at least 60% of its employees who are not already 5% plus shareholders (or their close relatives).
The bottom line
The accountants and business brokers who dismiss EOTs are looking at a snapshot. In that snapshot, the company pays for itself, and the owner seems to gain little. But a business shouldn’t be looked at in this way. Owners age, energy fades, technology moves on, and an owner-dependent company can lose much of its value before anyone notices.
Seen over the full life of the business, the sale to an EOT lets you sell at a fair price while the business is still strong and you only pay 12% tax on your gain. The sale to an EOT also offers you a continuing role in running the business and developing new leaders whilst also protects the jobs of the people who helped you build the business and keeping a valued employer in the local community. It all makes a great deal of sense.
If you are starting to think about your exit, the best time to have that conversation is a number of years before you wish to retire.
